Research Articles

Want to Seek 'Significant' Alpha? Look Beyond Dividend Stocks

Julie C - Wednesday, April 13, 2011
On March 30, 2011 an author that I have a great deal of respect for published an article titled "Investors who seek Alpha should seek out dividend stocks". Although I share an appreciation and penchant for owning quality dividend paying growth stocks, I also took exception to the innuendo and conclusions that his article presented. Ironically, the article started out with one of my favorite and most cherished quotes by Thomas H. Huxley:
"The deepest sin against the human mind is to believe things without evidence."
The opening of the article, utilizing this extremely relevant quote, stirred up a great deal of fear on my part. I was fearful because the article suggested that a study, which the article quotes and is primarily based on, alleges to prove that dividend stocks outperform non-dividend stocks. Therefore, at least to my way of thinking, initially suggests that investors who want the best returns should ignore non-dividend paying stocks, and should seek out only dividend stocks. I believe this is a classic example of a "muddy study" and FEAR as I use it here is an acronym for - False Evidence Appearing Real.
Of course, my real fear is that articles and studies like those represented in the above article will mislead prospective investors into ignoring non-dividend paying stocks when developing their investment plans. Later in this article, I will present evidence that the greatest returns and most significant Alpha generation will be earned from fast-growing non-dividend paying stocks. When very exciting and dynamic high quality companies are in the sweet spot of their growth phases, they rarely pay dividends. Moreover, this is also the phase where they make the most money for their shareholders in the shortest period of time, and if the principle of valuation is adhered to, at very reasonable levels of risk.
Earnings Growth and Valuation the True Drivers of Return
In a nutshell, this is my problem: First and foremost, I intend to demonstrate that dividends are not drivers of return. Instead, dividends are a component of return and not a creator. The true drivers and creators of return are earnings growth, but only when purchased at sound valuation. Consequently, the reason that dividend paying stocks tend to produce strong performance is due to the fact that the underlying company paying the dividends generates stable and growing earnings. Dividends come from the company's earnings and are expressed as a payout ratio. But it's the earnings that generate both capital appreciation and dividends and dividend growth.
To clarify even further, two companies generating the same earnings growth will tend to produce similar long-term returns for their shareholders. Of course this is true only as long as valuations are consistent and aligned with the underlying company’s earnings growth. Also, it's important to recognize that the capital appreciation component of return comes from the market capitalizing a given level of earnings. This is expressed as the price earnings ratio or PE. The income component of a common stock, which comes from dividends, will be in addition to the capital appreciation component. The two together make up total return. However, the market tends to recognize the additional return that dividends offer, by applying a higher multiple to the dividend payer. In essence, this can partially mitigate some of the dividend advantage, but usually not all of it.
On the other hand, a company with consistent and very fast-growing earnings will outperform a company with less earnings growth regardless of whether it pays a dividend or not. However, to take this thesis one step farther, it is rare to find a dividend paying stock with super fast earnings growth. For the most part, companies only start paying dividends when the very fast phase of their growth matures into moderate or slower growth rates. With growth slowing, dividends are offered because retained earnings are no longer needed to fund high growth. Therefore, the companies will reward shareholders with dividend income to augment their now muted capital appreciation potential.
The Key Distinguishing Factor
From what has been written thus far, it should be recognized that most dividend-paying companies will generate solid long-term returns through the combination of growth and income. The primary reason for this is, because in order to pay a dividend, the underlying company has to have solid earnings to support the dividend. In other words, dividend paying stocks tend to have good earnings, which as previously stated, is the primary driver of return. Consequently, dividend paying stocks will, as the studies indicate, outperform almost all non-dividend paying companies that have poor earnings. Therefore, on this basis at least, dividend paying stocks will outperform non-dividend paying stocks with lousy business models.
But here is the distinguishing factor, and the reason why we were compelled to author this article. The research will be hard-pressed to find any dividend paying stocks that can outperform a true growth stock. We define the true growth stock as a company that generates consistently strong earnings growth in excess of 20% or greater per annum. Here we would add that although they are very rare, the researcher may find a few dividend paying stocks that have historical earnings growth of 20% or better. More than likely the researcher would also discover that these companies will tend to offer yields in the 1% to 2% category.
However, once the earnings growth of the true growth stock exceeds 25% or better, there will be no dividend paying stocks that could be found with better long-term performance. More simply stated, there are no examples that we can find of dividend paying stocks outperforming very fast-growing true growth stocks.
Therefore, our main point is that, it is erroneous and misleading for anyone to categorically state the position that dividend paying stocks outperform non-dividend paying stocks. This statement can only be justified by grossly over-generalizing this asset class. There are far too many different classifications of common stocks than merely breaking them down into dividend paying or non-dividend paying. If a study is using classifications this broad, then we contend that the results offer no real meaning or insight. We would consider it a travesty of analysis which could mislead investors into ignoring the best-performing category of common stocks (non-dividend paying) high growth stocks.
The Good, the Great and the Ugly
To paraphrase the title of a famous “Spaghetti Western”, we are going to look at three groups of stocks in order to conduct our own mini-study of dividend paying stocks versus non-dividend paying stocks. We're calling these groups the good (dividend paying moderate to moderately high growth), the great (very fast growth no dividend) and the ugly (lousy earnings records mostly no dividends). However, instead of relying on merely crunching a bunch of statistical datasets, we intend to go deeper and faster via our F.A.S.T. Graphs™ research tool.
We have screened our database which is comprised of 10,257 common stocks. Of this group, there are 4051 stocks that pay dividends, and 6206 that do not. In order to offer a fair comparison to the study cited at the beginning of this article, we have calculated performance over the same calendar years 1993 to 2007 time period. (Note that many of the companies in our database were not in business over this entire timeframe and were therefore excluded).
Our first screen was to break the universe down into dividend paying versus non-dividend paying companies. Next, we screened each of these two subsets based on earnings growth, highest to lowest. What we discovered, is also what our common sense indicated. Companies with very poor earnings growth were the worst performers, whether they pay dividends or not. The best performers were the companies that generated the highest historical earnings growth and, contrary to many other studies, paid no dividends. In the middle, was a group of moderate to moderately high earnings generators where the majority did pay a dividend which grew consistent with their earnings growth.
For the sake of brevity the following tables list 15 examples of each of our three categories. We could have produced many more examples of each category, but feel that the examples cited tell the story. Although we believe the tables reflect our point very effectively, at the end of the tables there will be a link to three short videos that we hope you will find both entertaining and enlightening. The videos should crystallize the important concept of performance as it relates to dividend paying and non-dividend paying companies alike. The companies are listed in order of highest to lowest performance for each category.
The Good-15 Blue-chip Dividend Paying Stalwarts
The Great-15 Very Fast-growing Non-dividend Paying True Growth Stocks
The Ugly-15 Non-dividend Paying Stocks with Poor Earnings Histories
We have produced three videos that provide a more comprehensive review of this article thesis than the tables above are capable of. The videos will review each of the companies listed. We will go through one company in each category above in the sequence: One good, then one great, and finally one ugly. This will enable the reader to receive a clear comparison of the true performance of each company in each of these categories. The videos look at the companies starting with the lowest returns and moving to the highest (reverse order of the tables). If you only have time to review one video, look at video three.
Conclusions
The author of the article that inspired us to write this retort is one that we admire a great deal. We believe that this author is the genuine article whose objectives are only of the highest order. Moreover, it was not our intent to make him wrong, nor was it our intent to denigrate the well-conducted study that he cited in his work. Our true purpose and goal was to add precision to what we held to be vagaries regarding investment performance and where it comes from. Like the author, and as best we can tell the authors of the study, we are believers in investing in high-quality dividend paying stocks. And, also like the author, we are confident that they represent an asset class capable of generating above-average results at controlled levels of risk. Consequently, we also believe that they can and perhaps even should be a major component of a prudent investor’s long-term investing strategy and plan.
On the other hand, we are concerned that investors seeking maximum total return are not discouraged from investigating attractive growth stocks. High-quality fast-growing companies with good balance sheets and otherwise solid fundamentals are not, in our opinion, the risky investments many people believe them to be. On the contrary most of the examples listed in our category labeled great are good quality companies with long histories of operating excellence and potentially bright futures. There are enough myths floating around the investment community, we should not perpetuate another one.
Dividend paying stocks are typically strong companies with solid earnings and fundamentals supporting them. We agree that generally speaking they produce strong performance at controlled levels of risk. However, they are not the best performing stocks, that title belongs to the high quality fastest growing growth stocks. Our next article will discuss how to identify and build a portfolio of high-quality fast-growing companies.
Disclosure: I am long JKHY, AFL, MDT, CLX, PG, JNJ, MCD, ABT, PEP, KMB, ESRX, MIDD, FISV.
Disclaimer: The opinions in this document are for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as a recommendation to buy or sell the stocks mentioned or to solicit transactions or clients. Past performance of the companies discussed may not continue and the companies may not achieve the earnings growth as predicted. The information in this document is believed to be accurate, but under no circumstances should a person act upon the information contained within. We do not recommend that anyone act upon any investment information without first consulting an investment advisor as to the suitability of such investments for his specific situation.
I am long , , , , , , , , , , , , .
Comments
Anonymous commented on 19-Oct-2012 02:32 AM
The must have summer
Canada Goose JacketsOutlet styles include the timeless denim and leather as well as cropped and trench-style style items.
Canada Goose Parkas Outletare great in winter for warmth; they can be great on different styles and can go with casual or formal looks.The
Canada Goose OutletExpedition Parka provides heavy-duty warmth thanks to its high-quality duck down insulation.It is not a novelty that military style tops the leading fashion trends
Canada Goose Jackets Outletdue to its refined and classic influences and qualities.
Anonymous commented on 19-Oct-2012 04:09 AM
Designs of this season give you the unlimited cool feelings in this cool summer. The new designs of Coach products in the Coach Outlet enrich our daily life.
Anonymous commented on 19-Oct-2012 10:21 AM
I understand that in Egyptian hieroglyphics Louis Vuitton Official Website the course of development from ideograms to phonetic writing can be studied.Regarding the craft,the goods fromCoach Outlet Store is tight,the seams are aligned and details emulate the designer's actual handbags.west plus southwest around the commune,Louis Vuitton Online Store is usually a pure gardening plus Commune.Coach Outlet Online The staff was adamant about the policy even though they acknowledged there was nothing stopping us from coming in the next day and purchasing from another shop girl.Louis Vuitton Outlet iphone cases I was excited to see this coat online since I love Louis Vuitton, and I needed a new coat like this.This Louis Vuitton Canada for sale belongs to the sounding just what are termed asLouis Vuitton vintage best sellers.

Post a Comment




Captcha Image


Testimonials


“I appreciate your work, Chuck. As a subscriber to FAST Graphs™, I use the tool to decide on whether to purchase additional shares of what I currently hold or to add a new holding. Your articles help me make full use of the tool and give other readers valuable information, if they take the time to learn. One of the biggest enhancements that I use is the FFO data added for MLPs and REITs.”


“When FAST Graphs™ were unavailable because of Hurricane Sandy, I realized how much I need them in order to make investment decisions.

(Wish I could be) Long FAST Graphs!!!”


“One more vote for the value of FAST Graphs™; just started a subscription to Chuck's great service (premium), and am having a ball analyzing so many stocks quickly.”


“I feel very ill-equipped to make investment decisions without Fast Graphs. :-)”


“Yesterday, I signed up for your F.A.S.T. Graphs™. It's a really amazing, valuable tool for checking over/undervaluation of stocks. Wish I had it years and years ago!!”


“Love the F.A.S.T. Graphs™: One glance and you know a whole lot.”


“About Chuck's F.A.S.T. Graphs™: They are invaluable to me in making decisions about the stocks I own (in addition to what you are saying about doing other research) and the ones I hope to own in the future.”


"Chuck -- Your proprietary F.A.S.T. Graphs™ are a VERY impressive tool!"


“If there were an Investor Hall of Fame for people who have helped others with their investing, and sharing valuable information, you and your F.A.S.T. Graphs™ would get one of my selections.”


“I love Chuck's F.A.S.T. Graphs™! Well worth the price of admission for what he gives you.”


"Chuck - Thank you for your well thought out articles. I tend to be a visual type of person so I really appreciate the F.A.S.T. Graphs™ approach."


"Great article, as always! I always look forward to your articles, and am especially eagerly awaiting your next in this series. I find the F.A.S.T. Graphs™ extremely helpful."


“Your F.A.S.T. Graphs™ put all of this in a single artful picture and the accompanying spreadsheets hammer home the point.”


“I use the F.A.S.T. Graphs™ method to evaluate all of my ideas. I recommend it for individual investors, since it helps them focus on data and get past the many emotional arguments.”


“I recently subscribed to the F.A.S.T. Graphs™, and these articles are helping me learn how to better use them. They really do give you a good quick look at the valuations picture. A much needed tool!”


“I also always appreciate the clear-cut information provided through your F.A.S.T. Graphs™ and articles.”


“Thanks, Chuck, for your F.A.S.T. Graphs™. Each of these graphs is worth 1,000 words in describing a company's growth, consistency and valuation. Thanks for sharing your graphs.”


“Thanks, Chuck. Love the F.A.S.T. Graphs™! It makes investing so much more clear.”


“Chuck's F.A.S.T. Graphs™: They are invaluable to me in making decisions about the stocks I own (in addition to what you are saying about doing other research) and the ones I hope to own in the future.”


”I am amazed at the usefulness of your F.A.S.T. Graphs™ and I plan on using them for a long time to come.”


“Chuck's F.A.S.T. Graphs™ will give you a tool to find those well chosen stocks...”


“Thanks for the F.A.S.T. Graphs™, Chuck. They are the best tool I've used.”


Recent Posts


Tags

JCI PCL HD TWX BBY LLY LEN growth Challengers ACOM fastgraphs GMCR mid-sized MAIN TIS DPS NPM true worth FISV NA INFY ENDP ECHO AAPL SLW DRI PNR market HCN KR NC WFM CACC BHP NKE ETN CM UTHR MSA BCOR PG SoundValuation WLP CAPE INGR DD FTI,HTZ BIIB interest rates technology dividend DTE GME MGRC SHPG EMR SFG ARRS DE market currents EWBC CBRL blue-chip Telecommunications BOBE blue chip food service CSCO KFT PRAA OZRK HNZ economy THO HSC WST FCFS DGX Overvalued CTBI AIRM Aristocrats CB marketvaluation investing for income,growth and income POT BBBY SBUX PNM BANF HighQuality ACM FAST BMTC CVX MDT C MDP CE CFR WSM utility stocks INWK due diligence RCII FB PB HOG BCR MSFT WEC ULTA BKH ADT CXRX ITW NSC Share Buybacks BNS investing stock WMT Stock Research Analysis GE XRX APEI GPCM Dividend Champions VRTU KMB CTAS ROSE F RAI OUTR CCK AFG AMAG SLGN CSX EBAY EE CATY AKRX DNB SEIC ESRX CHE 3NSRGY VZ DHR ROST RBC BLK retirement value trap dividend paying stocks CHD TGH KMT stock analysis BHB AVD TICC MNST JSFT NROM SWKS JCOM UEPS ENSG ASNA macro AAN DollarCostAverging DKS CAT BOFI ODFL SJM ACI AGLP APD SILVER short ideas RSG GD SHR Market Outlook JNJ CELG OKE BF.B BAX ED Champions BRLI earnings CAH BPL MA AFL,CVX,ED,JNJ,MCD,PG,SWK,T,WMT,TGT,ABM,AFL,BEN,BMS,CB,CBSH,CTBI BR KO MNK WU MMM BAC DGAS IR WBA GOOGL DELL RTN CRLI MSCC EXC PCLN BMO BMS AMT MELI DividendAristocrats COO VAL SO VMI SPY DOM dividend-growth SYNA WASH ABM SNI CASY UNM high-yield TMP GWW MNTX AM InterestRates MRK SBRA ACR FC PEP FLIC CBI BG growth stocks ABC biotech GT FOMC HSNI value AMZN HGT DTEGY IDA COP AET ADM MAT TOT HCI SCG AFSI NSR TUP DLPH V diversified machinery Materials CNSL Yield DDS ALTE FDX UN SUBX HP PFE Consumer discretionary EXLS CPB NTES OGE AMGN FairValuation FBHS VTR SNCR WRLD KO,CLX,CELG,JCP,GT,MSI,PEP,ED BIDU ABT MGA CLX HCA MNR POR AVP EAT NVS treasury ITW, CL RRD OSIS PEG URI DividendChampions FLO LINE AB CSL X O PKG IBN BLL intrinsic value,stocks,earnings,fundamentals,stock research tool,due diligence fair valuation long-term growth SCHW consumer IBM ConsumerDiscretionary hyper growth stocks stock research long-term APH BCE stocks GOOG SIVB OHI,EPR,WPG,JLL intrinsic value PNRA POM IPAR SYT TWGP CGY SCL act capital appreciation LKQ UNH MYL JOY CTRX RSO EPHC MHP HRS suvivorship basis FRED STE BH PCP RDS.A LLL investing for total return BWP SPLS TE Utilities cyclical RY EK COST SON LMT LL RMD long ideas MAN SYY PRGO MKC DMRC long TRV TEVA DividendIncome CTCM INTC SNH CHS HBI Bond,TGT,UTX ORI Macro view TGI AEG GAS CNC PII BRS GPC TSM SXL long-term investing highqualityR BMRC MCY BOKF PPG CTL ACE MGEE DFS HCBK UNP ITC GOLD ATW DOW investment CanadianBanks MIDD RIMM AFAM XOM NOG WY earnings growth DECK CAM MTW CTG CTSH R HE sell TNGO CACI intrinsicvalue INT SYK ETR FOSL DR ANTM TNC NEE InformationTech DAN ADP SHW PAG TROW cash flow AAP LXU DTV investing for income BEN UL FL STMP MCHP cashflow M DRC SBR EMC FAF FRAN ARLP FairlyValued QCOM GES D FF HIBB ALB AZO TSCO ETP dividendGrowth HCP LH GNTX BNS. DIS THC SAVE FDO AFL Utilities Sector ABBV market timing THRM CLX,EMR ED:SCG KALU CVX,SWK,MCD,TGT,PG,WMT,JNJ,MDT,AFT,T,ED ATHM FAST Graphs POWR dividends REXX JWML.Y GPS US Economy SU dividend growth free cash flow value-oriented HSY DVA beta biotechnology WIN AA TIF JRN RRC WGL Aristocrat BEAV PortfolioDesign BAP CMI Fundamentals long-term returns COH dividend income SAM SHOO SWK FUL PDFS ZBRA IR, JPM RJF fundamental stock research tool LTM Dividend Ideas T dividend-paying mid-cap AXP dividend paying CR ESI healthcare GIS WMT,ROST,GIS,GE,JNJ,KO HAS WHR portfolio stock research tool MPW total return AMP machinery EMR, MMM JAZZ VRX CERN GPI XEL ICLR AMCX HRL NOC CKSW BDX THFF PBI RKT PRXL CVS CBU TGT DOV AMG CINF LO TAC CIO JKHY AEP MCD LOW WVR BigFive,Canadian Industrial SWFT BWLD LQDT MO MCK NSRGY ORCL OHI ACN KSS Contenders KCAP GEOS ANDE ZUMZ DORM MATW P regional banks SIG banks PM DRIP MHS TEF FTR TU SRCE VCO HII value investing ONE NLY best-of-breed HON Valuation AOS K UTX CRI PNW OXY Buffett RSG,RTN KMP EnergySector UHS EV ACQ PSX OII GLT TEG: WEC: OKS COL AZZ AGN LZB WAG QCOR GrowthOriented fair value PPL DLR dividends,earnings growth stockResearchTool dividend growth investing fast-growing MTZ REITs WWW TXT PFG FinancialSector ECL WFC suvivorship RS VVC AIG CPN BA MUR AMBN GILD CLR JWN VFC NFLX HPQ dividendpaying CLF

Archive

Testimonials


“I appreciate your work, Chuck. As a subscriber to FAST Graphs™, I use the tool to decide on whether to purchase additional shares of what I currently hold or to add a new holding. Your articles help me make full use of the tool and give other readers valuable information, if they take the time to learn. One of the biggest enhancements that I use is the FFO data added for MLPs and REITs.”


“When FAST Graphs™ were unavailable because of Hurricane Sandy, I realized how much I need them in order to make investment decisions.

(Wish I could be) Long FAST Graphs!!!”


“One more vote for the value of FAST Graphs™; just started a subscription to Chuck's great service (premium), and am having a ball analyzing so many stocks quickly.”


“I feel very ill-equipped to make investment decisions without Fast Graphs. :-)”


“Yesterday, I signed up for your F.A.S.T. Graphs™. It's a really amazing, valuable tool for checking over/undervaluation of stocks. Wish I had it years and years ago!!”


“Love the F.A.S.T. Graphs™: One glance and you know a whole lot.”


“About Chuck's F.A.S.T. Graphs™: They are invaluable to me in making decisions about the stocks I own (in addition to what you are saying about doing other research) and the ones I hope to own in the future.”


"Chuck -- Your proprietary F.A.S.T. Graphs™ are a VERY impressive tool!"


“If there were an Investor Hall of Fame for people who have helped others with their investing, and sharing valuable information, you and your F.A.S.T. Graphs™ would get one of my selections.”


“I love Chuck's F.A.S.T. Graphs™! Well worth the price of admission for what he gives you.”


"Chuck - Thank you for your well thought out articles. I tend to be a visual type of person so I really appreciate the F.A.S.T. Graphs™ approach."


"Great article, as always! I always look forward to your articles, and am especially eagerly awaiting your next in this series. I find the F.A.S.T. Graphs™ extremely helpful."


“Your F.A.S.T. Graphs™ put all of this in a single artful picture and the accompanying spreadsheets hammer home the point.”


“I use the F.A.S.T. Graphs™ method to evaluate all of my ideas. I recommend it for individual investors, since it helps them focus on data and get past the many emotional arguments.”


“I recently subscribed to the F.A.S.T. Graphs™, and these articles are helping me learn how to better use them. They really do give you a good quick look at the valuations picture. A much needed tool!”


“I also always appreciate the clear-cut information provided through your F.A.S.T. Graphs™ and articles.”


“Thanks, Chuck, for your F.A.S.T. Graphs™. Each of these graphs is worth 1,000 words in describing a company's growth, consistency and valuation. Thanks for sharing your graphs.”


“Thanks, Chuck. Love the F.A.S.T. Graphs™! It makes investing so much more clear.”


“Chuck's F.A.S.T. Graphs™: They are invaluable to me in making decisions about the stocks I own (in addition to what you are saying about doing other research) and the ones I hope to own in the future.”


”I am amazed at the usefulness of your F.A.S.T. Graphs™ and I plan on using them for a long time to come.”


“Chuck's F.A.S.T. Graphs™ will give you a tool to find those well chosen stocks...”


“Thanks for the F.A.S.T. Graphs™, Chuck. They are the best tool I've used.”