Research Articles

Based on Real Math The S&P 500 Is Fairly Valued

Chuck Carnevale - Wednesday, October 24, 2012

As investors, we do not believe in forecasting stock markets or stock prices on individual stocks. Instead, we approach investing as the process of calculating intrinsic value based on fundamentals. To us, the most important fundamental to be considered when evaluating the True Worth™ of a market or a common stock is earnings. Therefore, it's important that the reader understands that this article is offered as a mathematical calculation of what the S&P 500 is actually worth based on earnings. The reason we believe this to be important is because we also believe that any deviations from fair value will ultimately self-correct.

As we will soon illustrate, in the short run the stock market has a penchant for grossly mispricing common stocks and broad indices. When this is occurring, it is extremely valuable and important for investors to be able to recognize extreme and/or erroneous valuations when they manifest. It is also our contention that the calculation of fair valuation is both practical and achievable. In contrast, we further believe that attempting to forecast short-term market or price movements to be an exercise in futility. When irrational behavior is rampant, there is no logic that can be applied.

Our point is, making investment decisions based on valuation is a sound exercise that will bear fruit long term. As already stated, in the shorter run prices can go beyond fair value or below it. But, inevitably stock prices will seek intrinsic values. Therefore, we believe that intrinsic value is something that can be trusted, whereas stock price volatility cannot. Admittedly, this is not as easy as we may be making it appear. The trick lies in forecasting future earnings as accurately as possible. The better you can do that, the more accurate your long-term forecast will be. But, once again, we contend that forecasting earnings can be done more accurately than attempting to forecast short-term price movement. On the other hand, this is easier to do on an individual company (business), than it is on a broad index like the S&P 500.

Historically Normal Valuations

When writing articles such as this, many authors tend to gravitate towards statistical references. And, although there can be value found through statistical analysis, it's also very easy to draw erroneous conclusions. With that said, there is a preponderance of historical data, and calculations based on that data, that the historical normal PE ratio for the S&P 500 is 15. However, even more importantly, we believe that there is a rational mathematical explanation for why a PE of 15 represents the proper average valuation for most companies, and therefore, an index like the S&P 500.

A detailed explanation of the mathematical validity of the PE equals 15 thesis is beyond the scope of this article. However, a brief explanation of the underlying principles should suffice. The normal PE of 15 is based on the reality that a stream of income generated from an investment is worth more than one times earnings. This is true even if the future income stream does not grow. In other words, if we assume, for example, an interest rate of 8.5% on a bond (of course bond yields are much lower than that today), we would discover that the bond is trading at approximately 12 times interest. Since the future income stream on a bond is fixed, it only stands to reason that a growing income stream, such as found on a stock, should also command a multiple greater than one, adjusted for risk.

That number has historically hovered around a PE of 15, because this represents an earnings yield of 6%-7%. This number is very close to the long-term historical returns that stocks have delivered on average. Admittedly, we have not provided significant proof of our statement based on what is written above. Instead, we are simply offering some hints as to how the normal PE of 15 can be justified. Put another way, there is a lot of research that suggests that the normal PE ratio for the S&P 500 over the past 100-plus years is 15. Additionally, there is further research that indicates that the normal PE ratio for the S&P 500 over the past 20 years has been closer to 20 (19.3 on our graph below). Our analysis, and a quick glance at the earnings and price correlated graph below, indicates that this higher than normal PE over the past 20 years can be mostly attributed to excessive overvaluation.

The S&P 500 via F.A.S.T. Graphs™

When looked at through the lens of our F.A.S.T. Graphs™ research tool, we can test theory and see how it applies in the real world. The following earnings and price correlated graph of the S&P 500 since calendar year 1994 tells some interesting stories. Perhaps the most interesting story is how the chart depicts two calculated PE ratios that equal the 20-year historical normal PE of approximately 20 (19.3), and the longer-term normal PE ratio of 15. In the first case, the PE of 20 (blue line with asterisks) was determined as the computer calculated the trimmed mean (outlier highs and lows trimmed to eliminate skewing) PE ratio for that time period. In the second case, the PE of 15 was determined by applying a widely-accepted formula for valuing businesses to the EPS growth rate of 7.5% for the S&P 500 since 1994.

The important takeaway from reviewing the earnings and price correlated graph is the visual depiction of how statistics can mislead. Clearly, the black monthly closing stock price line often deviated significantly above and below the trimmed mean PE ratio of 20. Therefore, even though it is statistically accurate to state that the normal PE over this time frame was 20, a quick visual shows how often that was not true. As previously stated, we believe that the graph vividly illustrates the meaning of the phrase “irrational exuberance." On the other hand, we believe the graph further vividly illustrates how the black monthly closing stock price line continuously attempted a reversion to the mean towards a historically significant normal PE of 15. The reader should note that although all data is plotted, when we draw a graph of 20 years, we only type in every other year’s data because of space restraints (Note the asterisks by the years at the top of the graph).

Conclusions

In conclusion, there continues to be a lot of opinion and speculation regarding whether the S&P 500, or the stock market, or stock prices in general are overvalued or not. From the perspective of earnings justified valuations as depicted in the graph above, at 14.1 times earnings, it is arguable that the S&P 500 is slightly undervalued at these levels. Moreover, taken directly from their website, the current forecast for operating earnings of the S&P 500 by Standard & Poor's Corp. is $101.33. If this forecast is accurate, this would imply a year-end fair value for the S&P 500 of approximately 1519.40.

Mathematically, it would indicate that the S&P 500 has approximately another 7.52% upside by year-end. Once again, this is not a prediction, instead this is a mathematical calculation based on applying a normal PE ratio of 15 to the current earnings expectations of the S&P 500. It is our intention to provide an updated F.A.S.T. Graphs™ on the S&P 500 periodically. If forecasts change, then so will the anticipated valuation expectations.

Disclosure: I have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours.

Disclaimer: The opinions in this document are for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as a recommendation to buy or sell the stocks mentioned or to solicit transactions or clients. Past performance of the companies discussed may not continue and the companies may not achieve the earnings growth as predicted. The information in this document is believed to be accurate, but under no circumstances should a person act upon the information contained within. We do not recommend that anyone act upon any investment information without first consulting an investment advisor as to the suitability of such investments for his specific situation.

Comments
Post has no comments.
Post a Comment




Captcha Image


Testimonials


“I appreciate your work, Chuck. As a subscriber to FAST Graphs™, I use the tool to decide on whether to purchase additional shares of what I currently hold or to add a new holding. Your articles help me make full use of the tool and give other readers valuable information, if they take the time to learn. One of the biggest enhancements that I use is the FFO data added for MLPs and REITs.”


“When FAST Graphs™ were unavailable because of Hurricane Sandy, I realized how much I need them in order to make investment decisions.

(Wish I could be) Long FAST Graphs!!!”


“One more vote for the value of FAST Graphs™; just started a subscription to Chuck's great service (premium), and am having a ball analyzing so many stocks quickly.”


“I feel very ill-equipped to make investment decisions without Fast Graphs. :-)”


“Yesterday, I signed up for your F.A.S.T. Graphs™. It's a really amazing, valuable tool for checking over/undervaluation of stocks. Wish I had it years and years ago!!”


“Love the F.A.S.T. Graphs™: One glance and you know a whole lot.”


“About Chuck's F.A.S.T. Graphs™: They are invaluable to me in making decisions about the stocks I own (in addition to what you are saying about doing other research) and the ones I hope to own in the future.”


"Chuck -- Your proprietary F.A.S.T. Graphs™ are a VERY impressive tool!"


“If there were an Investor Hall of Fame for people who have helped others with their investing, and sharing valuable information, you and your F.A.S.T. Graphs™ would get one of my selections.”


“I love Chuck's F.A.S.T. Graphs™! Well worth the price of admission for what he gives you.”


"Chuck - Thank you for your well thought out articles. I tend to be a visual type of person so I really appreciate the F.A.S.T. Graphs™ approach."


"Great article, as always! I always look forward to your articles, and am especially eagerly awaiting your next in this series. I find the F.A.S.T. Graphs™ extremely helpful."


“Your F.A.S.T. Graphs™ put all of this in a single artful picture and the accompanying spreadsheets hammer home the point.”


“I use the F.A.S.T. Graphs™ method to evaluate all of my ideas. I recommend it for individual investors, since it helps them focus on data and get past the many emotional arguments.”


“I recently subscribed to the F.A.S.T. Graphs™, and these articles are helping me learn how to better use them. They really do give you a good quick look at the valuations picture. A much needed tool!”


“I also always appreciate the clear-cut information provided through your F.A.S.T. Graphs™ and articles.”


“Thanks, Chuck, for your F.A.S.T. Graphs™. Each of these graphs is worth 1,000 words in describing a company's growth, consistency and valuation. Thanks for sharing your graphs.”


“Thanks, Chuck. Love the F.A.S.T. Graphs™! It makes investing so much more clear.”


“Chuck's F.A.S.T. Graphs™: They are invaluable to me in making decisions about the stocks I own (in addition to what you are saying about doing other research) and the ones I hope to own in the future.”


”I am amazed at the usefulness of your F.A.S.T. Graphs™ and I plan on using them for a long time to come.”


“Chuck's F.A.S.T. Graphs™ will give you a tool to find those well chosen stocks...”


“Thanks for the F.A.S.T. Graphs™, Chuck. They are the best tool I've used.”


Recent Posts


Tags

CHS UEPS AGLP AMZN DOV PPG Challengers THRM blue chip SHOO MTZ MDT GNTX FF LH MKC ACI POWR market JAZZ Buffett DAN BBY XRX CNSL AA BMS WAG suvivorship LOW CXRX RS CRLI FISV economy Consumer discretionary marketvaluation STE STMP fastgraphs VMI CAM LLL GrowthOriented CTG WBA RBC machinery FBHS WST HCBK investment TROW ACN RAI NEE AFL SFG APH DLR JCOM OII BHP EAT retirement HBI ACM FRAN HSC WIN CATY APEI Aristocrat MAN MGEE HCP KMT TWX Telecommunications R GIS SLGN ETR KO AFG UN TGI TSM PCLN ARRS SEIC INFY sell SPLS TAC Contenders free cash flow SIG VFC dividend paying HIBB TE EXC VTR ED:SCG consumer HGT COP value-oriented BDX CRI BMO AMT HNZ SAVE long-term investing ALB RCII VVC MNR REXX BH ABC TICC DR Aristocrats best-of-breed TIS DMRC ADP SPY ENSG DTE OKE FLIC BKH JKHY ADT ESRX UL AEP PRGO ACR ACE PRXL APD CE TNGO DividendChampions EMR GME true worth MGRC dividendpaying CACC IDA IR, portfolio PG KO,CLX,CELG,JCP,GT,MSI,PEP,ED Dividend Champions EXLS SHW MNK Utilities Sector NPM BOFI CASY SAM AMAG THO GOOGL long ideas JSFT DLPH HSNI PM T BOKF PCP OSIS CTL WMT WVR ACOM DIS CLX CPB ENDP MCY CMI FLO long-term growth highqualityR MTW JCI cyclical BCE ROST value investing QCOM RJF TSCO ESI AM OHI BRS blue-chip TEVA UHS Materials CTSH LKQ CL HAS SNCR Stock Research Analysis CAH DTEGY DRC AAPL WLP InformationTech TEG: WEC: PNRA CM D NSR FAF growth HRL suvivorship basis capital appreciation TRV AZO high-yield LZB LO WFM DECK stocks long-term WHR ACQ GPC SIVB AVP UNH BigFive,Canadian CCK PPL GMCR POR EWBC ARLP NKE ULTA AB AVD ITC AMP stockResearchTool GEOS intrinsic value,stocks,earnings,fundamentals,stock research tool,due diligence F VRTU MSCC LL CKSW SWFT macro CTAS ANTM URI ITW, AZZ JWML.Y biotech LTM CAPE ECHO DGX ICLR CPN KCAP NVS HON ABT MHP MAIN KSS fast-growing fair valuation KFT SHPG CVS PKG ITW Dividend Ideas CACI CSL ZBRA GES TNC act WRLD PNW CR FL US Economy healthcare dividend growth investing VCO cash flow BWLD WEC utility stocks DE investing for total return ECL DPS CSX MGA AEG GLT GAS PNM LINE dividend growth EBAY PNR MUR FUL JPM HD Utilities M C PEP CFR BCR EMC banks BBBY XOM RSG PEG OUTR AFL,CVX,ED,JNJ,MCD,PG,SWK,T,WMT,TGT,ABM,AFL,BEN,BMS,CB,CBSH,CTBI GPS DRI HOG CERN RY FOMC TUP RRC market currents CBU FTR CSCO FAST Graphs UTHR PAG HRS GPI BWP FairlyValued growth stocks HSY PFE DollarCostAverging long-term returns K ZUMZ AKRX Champions DHR MCHP POT INTC RSO EPHC intrinsic value RIMM ALTE WSM VRX LLY TIF IBM BNS. short ideas TGT THC JOY MCK SYK Overvalued EMR, MMM GWW OGE MCD AMCX GILD ABM investing AET CIO FCFS LXU GOLD ABBV FB FinancialSector MRK X INT SJM KMB PII CLX,EMR GD MA GT MIDD stock research tool AAP P InterestRates stock KALU POM BCOR cashflow MHS biotechnology HP CHD SRCE AFSI MNTX BNS RMD dividend-paying food service QCOR NLY CHE AOS MAT IBN DDS dividend COH CB BF.B earnings growth FAST earnings NA TU AMBN EV OKS SoundValuation DRIP DGAS PDFS BIDU MPW OHI,EPR,WPG,JLL EE RRD NOG HCI PCL EnergySector BMTC AAN WMT,ROST,GIS,GE,JNJ,KO 3NSRGY SNI NFLX fundamental stock research tool beta NROM SYT BRLI FairValuation BAX BOBE market timing DOW LEN WASH HCN HE MATW ADM NTES Share Buybacks DOM ROSE NSRGY stock research JNJ OXY CanadianBanks ED MELI Market Outlook GPCM MMM BIIB MDP Yield PBI fair value UNM SU PRAA SBUX SWKS BANF RSG,RTN dividend-growth MO LMT GOOG MSFT DELL CVX XEL DividendAristocrats Bond,TGT,UTX BHB DividendIncome BMRC PB CTCM ETN stock analysis O REITs intrinsicvalue mid-cap value Valuation LQDT SO DKS DNB MNST ASNA CLF SWK HighQuality PFG UTX RDS.A FDO TGH IPAR CBI CTBI KR CAT ORI Macro view due diligence UNP CBRL GE HII TXT treasury V CLR value trap AXP THFF VZ Fundamentals RKT HPQ SCHW SILVER ATW PortfolioDesign mid-sized AGN dividendGrowth FOSL FTI,HTZ COST technology CINF ETP OZRK total return CVX,SWK,MCD,TGT,PG,WMT,JNJ,MDT,AFT,T,ED AMGN SUBX COL BPL TOT RTN dividend income FRED INWK AMG SNH CTRX dividends,earnings growth BA AIG BAP FC dividends NC MSA SBR JWN DTV hyper growth stocks CELG BR BG diversified machinery ONE DORM investing for income,growth and income NSC ODFL SBRA SYNA BEAV SHR ORCL WFC TWGP HCA MYL ANDE TEF BLK AFAM SYY TMP COO WY investing for income SXL DD EK IR SCL NOC CGY KMP VAL WU SCG interest rates INGR ATHM SON BLL dividend paying stocks BAC WGL CNC DVA SLW BEN long Industrial AIRM JRN DFS WWW regional banks PSX ConsumerDiscretionary FDX

Archive

Testimonials


“I appreciate your work, Chuck. As a subscriber to FAST Graphs™, I use the tool to decide on whether to purchase additional shares of what I currently hold or to add a new holding. Your articles help me make full use of the tool and give other readers valuable information, if they take the time to learn. One of the biggest enhancements that I use is the FFO data added for MLPs and REITs.”


“When FAST Graphs™ were unavailable because of Hurricane Sandy, I realized how much I need them in order to make investment decisions.

(Wish I could be) Long FAST Graphs!!!”


“One more vote for the value of FAST Graphs™; just started a subscription to Chuck's great service (premium), and am having a ball analyzing so many stocks quickly.”


“I feel very ill-equipped to make investment decisions without Fast Graphs. :-)”


“Yesterday, I signed up for your F.A.S.T. Graphs™. It's a really amazing, valuable tool for checking over/undervaluation of stocks. Wish I had it years and years ago!!”


“Love the F.A.S.T. Graphs™: One glance and you know a whole lot.”


“About Chuck's F.A.S.T. Graphs™: They are invaluable to me in making decisions about the stocks I own (in addition to what you are saying about doing other research) and the ones I hope to own in the future.”


"Chuck -- Your proprietary F.A.S.T. Graphs™ are a VERY impressive tool!"


“If there were an Investor Hall of Fame for people who have helped others with their investing, and sharing valuable information, you and your F.A.S.T. Graphs™ would get one of my selections.”


“I love Chuck's F.A.S.T. Graphs™! Well worth the price of admission for what he gives you.”


"Chuck - Thank you for your well thought out articles. I tend to be a visual type of person so I really appreciate the F.A.S.T. Graphs™ approach."


"Great article, as always! I always look forward to your articles, and am especially eagerly awaiting your next in this series. I find the F.A.S.T. Graphs™ extremely helpful."


“Your F.A.S.T. Graphs™ put all of this in a single artful picture and the accompanying spreadsheets hammer home the point.”


“I use the F.A.S.T. Graphs™ method to evaluate all of my ideas. I recommend it for individual investors, since it helps them focus on data and get past the many emotional arguments.”


“I recently subscribed to the F.A.S.T. Graphs™, and these articles are helping me learn how to better use them. They really do give you a good quick look at the valuations picture. A much needed tool!”


“I also always appreciate the clear-cut information provided through your F.A.S.T. Graphs™ and articles.”


“Thanks, Chuck, for your F.A.S.T. Graphs™. Each of these graphs is worth 1,000 words in describing a company's growth, consistency and valuation. Thanks for sharing your graphs.”


“Thanks, Chuck. Love the F.A.S.T. Graphs™! It makes investing so much more clear.”


“Chuck's F.A.S.T. Graphs™: They are invaluable to me in making decisions about the stocks I own (in addition to what you are saying about doing other research) and the ones I hope to own in the future.”


”I am amazed at the usefulness of your F.A.S.T. Graphs™ and I plan on using them for a long time to come.”


“Chuck's F.A.S.T. Graphs™ will give you a tool to find those well chosen stocks...”


“Thanks for the F.A.S.T. Graphs™, Chuck. They are the best tool I've used.”